SC Rejects Delayed Appeals Against Lulu Mall Resolution Plan
Companies Retail

SC Rejects Delayed Appeals Against Lulu Mall Resolution Plan

Supreme Court questions steep ticket and snack rates, warns empty theatres if prices stay high; hearing on Karnataka cap resumes Nov 25.

Purchasers of commercial units in Manjeera Mall filed appeals beyond the 45-day statutory limit, prompting the Supreme Court to set aside two NCLAT orders and dismiss their challenge

 

 

The Supreme Court has overturned two orders of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) that allowed three purchasers of commercial units in Manjeera Mall to challenge the approval of Lulu International Shopping Malls’ resolution plan for Manjeera Retail beyond the prescribed limitation period.

A Bench comprising Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva ruled that the NCLAT had erred in condoning the delay and subsequently refusing to recall its decision. The purchasers had contested the resolution plan, arguing that the money paid by them for commercial units had been classified as customer advances rather than recognised as claims of financial creditors.

The insolvency proceedings against Manjeera Retail Holdings were initiated by the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Hyderabad, on July 18, 2023. Lulu International Shopping Malls emerged as the successful resolution applicant after securing unanimous approval from the Committee of Creditors (CoC). The NCLT subsequently approved its resolution plan on March 26, 2025.

Lulu informed the Supreme Court that it had already invested Rs 271.52 crore towards implementing the approved plan. However, three purchasers approached the NCLAT on May 11, 2025, challenging the NCLT’s approval. The appellate tribunal admitted their appeals after condoning the delay under Section 4 of the Limitation Act, 1963.

Under Section 61(2) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), an appeal against an NCLT order must be filed within 30 days. The provision allows an additional 15 days for delays to be condoned, subject to sufficient grounds. In this case, the purchasers approached the appellate tribunal on the 46th day, exceeding the maximum permissible period.

The Supreme Court observed that the NCLAT had misinterpreted its May 7, 2025, judgment in the Tata Steel Limited matter while considering the purchasers’ appeals. It clarified that a judicial interpretation of the law takes effect from the date of its pronouncement and must guide the application of the relevant statutory provision. An earlier order that conflicts with such a legal position cannot be protected unless it has attained finality.

The Bench also clarified the distinction between reviewing and recalling an order under the IBC. Although the NCLAT does not have the authority to review its own decisions, it can recall an order by invoking its inherent powers under Rule 11 of the NCLAT Rules, 2016, in appropriate circumstances.

In reaching its conclusion, the Supreme Court referred to the five-judge NCLAT ruling in Union Bank of India versus Dinkar T Venkatasubramanian, which was subsequently upheld by the apex court. It also relied on its judgment in Greater Noida Industrial Development Authority versus Prabhjit Singh Soni concerning the tribunal’s inherent powers.

The Bench held that the NCLAT should have exercised its powers to recall the earlier order once the established legal position was brought to its attention. It further found that the purchasers had not demonstrated sufficient grounds to justify condonation of the delay.

The appellate tribunal had relied on the fact that May 10, 2025, was the second Saturday of the month to justify extending the limitation period to the 46th day. The Supreme Court rejected this reasoning, finding it insufficient to support the admission of appeals filed beyond the statutory deadline.

Consequently, the Supreme Court set aside the NCLAT orders dated October 10, 2025, and February 10, 2026. It dismissed the three purchasers’ appeals challenging the approval of Lulu’s resolution plan on the grounds that they were time-barred.

Leave a Reply